The highest court in the Russian Far Eastern region of Kamchatka has
ordered the cancellation of an earlier ruling recognizing a 1942 Disney
cartoon depicting Donald Duck’s adventures in Nazi Germany as ‘extremist
material’.
The ruling in question was passed by the city court of Petropavlovsk
Kamchatsky in 2010. Back then the judge gave a six-month suspended
sentence to a local resident for distributing extremist materials over
the internet.
The propaganda included the Oscar-winning animation ‘Der Fuehrer's Face’
that the accused called ‘Donald Duck and Fascism’ in Russian and
because of this the film has been included in the Russian federal list
of banned extremist materials.
When prosecutors discovered this fact they filed a cassation with the
regional court explaining that the video is a classic Walt Disney
cartoon made within the framework of an anti-Nazi propaganda campaign.
They also wrote that the film contains no calls to extremism - on the contrary, it depicts Nazi ideology in satirical and mocking forms. The court agreed with this statement and also ruled that the film’s characters are not promoting violence against anyone. ‘Der Fuehrer's Face’, also known under the title ‘Donald Duck in Nutzi Land’, was created in the US in 1943 and in the same year its director, Jack Kinney, received the Academy Award for best animated short.
Current Russian law bans any public calls for extremism or attempts to humiliate people and provides that such actions should be punished with up to five years in prison. This applies to internet posts as well as mass media publications. Decisions on the subject are made by regional courts, but once something is recognized as extremism anywhere in the country, this material is included in the federal list of banned information.
They also wrote that the film contains no calls to extremism - on the contrary, it depicts Nazi ideology in satirical and mocking forms. The court agreed with this statement and also ruled that the film’s characters are not promoting violence against anyone. ‘Der Fuehrer's Face’, also known under the title ‘Donald Duck in Nutzi Land’, was created in the US in 1943 and in the same year its director, Jack Kinney, received the Academy Award for best animated short.
Current Russian law bans any public calls for extremism or attempts to humiliate people and provides that such actions should be punished with up to five years in prison. This applies to internet posts as well as mass media publications. Decisions on the subject are made by regional courts, but once something is recognized as extremism anywhere in the country, this material is included in the federal list of banned information.
No comments:
Post a Comment