The Texas cases are telling in that there are two dead police
officers as a result of not identifying themselves as law enforcement
while breaking into private residences…
In the first stage of what is known as general
adaptation syndrome, a recognized natural response among all vertebrates
and many other organisms is hyperarousal or acute stress response. In
its more recognizable name, the “fight or flight” response is a natural
physiological reaction to a perceived harmful event, attack, or a threat
to one’s survival. Without delving into the actual hormonal secretions
involved, animals’ sympathetic nervous systems react to a chemical
discharge that primes them to either run away or stand and face a
threat. Human beings experience the fight or flight response to their
safety, but when they are denied egress from danger, their only option
is to stand and fight.
Regardless of what one thinks of the obscene NRA and
ALEC “stand your ground laws,” most Americans would support its
original iteration known as the “Castle Doctrine.” The principle that
every American has the right to defend their family from armed intruders
breaking into their home should be universally applied to all
Americans, but it appears to be reserved solely for white people, at
least in Texas.
First, in Somerville Texas in mid-December, a white
man, Henry Goedrich Magee, was awoken before 6 a.m. to intruders
breaking into his mobile home. Fearing for his and his pregnant
girlfriend’s safety, Magee grabbed a firearm and opened fire on the
intruders killing a Burleson County law enforcement officer. Sgt. Adam
Sowers was fatally wounded by Magee while leading an armed team during
an early morning unannounced “no-knock” marijuana raid. A
couple of months later a Texas grand jury rightfully refused to indict
Mr. Magee citing his sincere belief that he feared for his and his
pregnant girlfriend’s life. The grand jury cleared him of any wrongdoing “as a completely reasonable act of self-defense.”
It is tragic a law enforcement officer lost his
life, and that Magee was so rightfully terrified he had no flight option
available and with a team of armed men breaking into his home exercised
the natural response of fighting for survival. That is a result of a
growing law enforcement practice across America of heavily-armed
SWAT teams breaking into private homes without identifying themselves
are police. A reasonable person might think that law enforcement
officials in Texas would rethink the “army-style” incursions into
private citizens’ homes, especially with the preponderance of gun
advocates in the state, but the concepts of “reasonable, Texas, and law
enforcement” in the same sentence is alien.
Reasonable law enforcement practice is so alien, in
fact, that armed teams breaking into Americans’ homes unannounced while
residents are sleeping resulted in another law enforcement officer’s
death less than six months after the Magee incident where the events
were nearly identical. In fact, the events were exactly identical except
for the prosecutor’s outrageous response.
In May, at about 5:30 a.m. in Killeen Texas, a SWAT team looking for marijuana broke into
a home occupied by Marvin Louis Guy and his wife. The SWAT team was
acting on a bogus, and unverified, tip off that drugs were on the
premises and being dealt from the home. A subsequent search found no
drugs or nothing indicating drug dealing. In fact, it is a real travesty
that there was nothing whatsoever to indicate to a reasonable person
that there was any reason a gang of armed men should have been breaking
into one’s home that makes the circumstances of the officer’s death all
the more tragic.
Subsequently, upon hearing the armed men breaking
into his home at the crack of dawn, Mr. Guy feared for his and his
wife’s life and sought to protect themselves and their property from
what they thought were armed intruders. The SWAT team attempting to
breach Mr. Guy’s home were implementing another “no-knock” raid, and a
Detective Dinwiddie and three other SWAT members were shot while
breaking into Mr. Guy’s home. Detective Dinwiddie died, one officer was
wounded, and two others were saved by body armor. The police press release
admitted Dinwiddie and the three other officers were shot while
breaking into Mr. Guy’s home without identifying themselves as law
enforcement; “The TRU was breaching the windows when the 49 year old male inside opened fire striking four officers.”
One might think that after the previous incident in
December, a reasonable prosecutor would assume that since the shooting
occurred during an early-morning break-in by armed men without
identifying themselves as police officers, it would be a case of
self-defense; but there is one major difference in the case. Mr. Guy is
African American, he lives in Texas, and despite fearing for his and his
wife’s life, he should have known that there are different standards
according to race in America. As a Black man he had no right to defend
himself according to the local prosecutor, and no grand jury cleared him
of wrongdoing “as a completely reasonable act of self-defense.”
The prosecutor, while announcing in open court that
Governor Rick Perry had just awarded the slain police officer’s family
with the Star of Texas award, promptly charged Mr. Guy with capital
murder and is seeking the death penalty in Dinwiddie’s death. He also
charged Guy with three counts of attempted capital murder for firing at
the other officers while they were breaking in his home. The Star of
Texas prize is given out each year to police and first responders killed
or injured in the line of duty; even when they break into a private
citizens home without identifying themselves as law enforcement or find
no evidence of contraband.
The idea of self-defense, particularly in one’s
private residence, should not be up for discussion, controversial, or an
issue involving law enforcement officers as victims of armed break-ins.
There has been an explosion of military-style SWAT raids known as
“no-knock” incursions that have resulted in death and injuries to
people’s pets, children, entire communities, and law enforcement
officers as well. Most are for non-violent, and often non-existent,
misdemeanor drug offenses that are in most cases a result of the
ridiculous and failed war on marijuana use; not drug cartels or major
drug traffickers. The number of SWAT deployments, with military hardware
and vehicles, across the nation has ballooned from a few hundred
annually in the 1970s, to a few thousand during the 1980s, to over 50,000 per year in 2010. Subsequently, many of the “military raids” are botched besides the two recent officer deaths in Texas as well as an 18-month old baby
in Georgia being injured by a SWAT grenade. Most of the botched raids
and subsequent law enforcement mistakes resulting in death never
actually make the news.
The Texas cases are telling in that there are two
dead police officers as a result of not identifying themselves as law
enforcement while breaking into private residences in the early morning
hours. It is also revealing that a grand jury found that a white man who
shot and killed what he thought was an armed intruder acted in
self-defense, while a Black man in identical circumstances is charged by
a prosecutor with capital murder and faces the death penalty.
Self-defense is supposed to be a right for all Americans, regardless of
race, and if lawmakers would comprehend that using marijuana should also
be a right, regardless of race, at least two Texas cops would be alive
and a Black man would not be facing the death penalty for “a completely
reasonable act of self-defense.”
No comments:
Post a Comment