When you're smiling, the whole world smiles with you, but when you're
laughing your neighbors complain of "mental agony, pain and public
nuisance". At least, they do in Mumbai where the High Court has ordered
members of a 'laughter yoga' club to restrain their joy. The judges have
told local police officers to find a way for the local residents of a
Mumbai suburb to have the last laugh in a long running legal battle over
whether the sound of laughter amounts to "aural aggression". The case
was brought by 78 year old lawyer Vinayak Shirsat and his family after
an informal yoga club started meeting in a lakeside gazebo by their
bungalow.
They complained that between 10 and 30 devotees
gathered outside their house every morning at 6am and started singing
devotional songs, clapping and exhorting one another to laugh out
louder. According to their lawyer, Veena Thadani, it is no laughing
matter. "It's true that laughter is contagious, but if 30 people laugh
every day in your window and you wake up to the sound of this cacophony
you do not start laughing. They encourage each other to laugh louder –
'laugh through your belly! Laugh through your eyes! Laugh through your
ears!' they shout," she said. Despite a number of rulings, the police
have not yet taken action against the laughing yogis because they are
not a formal registered club.
Mumbai's
High Court judges have now voiced their frustration that their order
has not been enforced. "Solve this problem. This is (an) unnecessary
headache ...
people coming and laughing outside your house,"
said Justice Bobde. Laughing yoga has grown in popularity throughout
the world after it was developed by Mumbai doctor Madan Kartaria, who
styles himself the 'Guru of giggling.' He began his 'movement' with just
five followers in the early 1990s and has since inspired 6000 'laughter
clubs' in 60 countries around the world. These clubs have proliferated
throughout India's public parks where groups of devotees throw back
their arms and heads in unison and laugh in exaggerated breathing
exercises.
Despite its 17 year history, crowds still gather to
enjoy the spectacle and in many cases laugh along with them. But
according to Veena Thadani no one is laughing in the upmarket Mumbai
suburb of Kurli, where residents are fighting for the right to be glum
in peace. "It's aural aggression. You can't be forced to hear sounds you
don't want to hear. Everyone is miserable because these activities are
outside their home every day. What if you want to get up late or you're
not feeling well? They're still waking you up with this cackling," she
said.