by Luke Baker and Andreas Rinke
German Chancellor Angela Merkel accused the United States
of an unacceptable breach of trust on Thursday after allegations that
the U.S. bugged her personal mobile phone, and she suggested
data-sharing agreements with Washington may need revising.
Arriving for a two-day summit in
Brussels where the broad economic and social policy agenda has been
overshadowed by allegations of eavesdropping by the U.S. National Security Agency against Italy, France and Germany, Merkel said she had told President Barack Obama in a telephone conversation late on Wednesday that the acts were unacceptable.
"It's not just about me but about every German citizen. We need to
have trust in our allies and partners, and this trust must now be
established once again," she told reporters.
"I repeat that spying among friends is not at all acceptable against anyone, and that goes for every citizen in Germany."
The stern words follow an
announcement by the German government on Wednesday that it had seen
evidence suggesting the chancellor's mobile was "monitored" by the NSA.
Germany's foreign minister has summoned the U.S. ambassador to Berlin
to discuss the issue, an event diplomats said had rarely happened in the
past 60 years.
White House spokesman Jay Carney said Obama had assured Merkel in
their telephone call that the United States "is not monitoring and will
not monitor" her communications, leaving open the possibility that it
had happened in the past.
The affair dredges up memories of eavesdropping by the Stasi secret
police in the former East Germany, where Merkel grew up, and is an
emotive topic for many Germans.
Following the unceasing flow of leaks by former U.S. data analyst
Edward Snowden, which revealed the reach of the NSA's data-collection
programs, Washington finds itself at odds with a host of important
allies, from Brazil to Saudi Arabia.
Germany's frustration follows outrage in France after Le Monde
newspaper reported the NSA had collected tens of thousands of French
phone records between December 2012 and January 2013, and an Italian
news magazine reported on Thursday that the NSA had monitored sensitive
Italian telecommunications.
The revelations could have an impact on major legislative and trade initiatives between the United States and the European Union, with some German lawmakers saying negotiations over an EU-U.S. free-trade agreement should be suspended.
Merkel, who has previously discussed a "no spying" agreement with
the United States, hinted that data-sharing deals with Washington may
need to be relooked at, a potentially damaging blow for U.S. efforts to
collect counter-terrorism information.
"To this end, we need to ask what we need, which data security
agreements we need, what transparency we need between the United States
of America and Europe," Merkel said.
"We are allies facing challenges together. But such an alliance can only be built on the basis of trust."
Merkel and Hollande discussed the spying allegations one-to-one
before the Brussels summit, with Hollande suggesting beforehand that he
intended to put the issue formally on the agenda.
While Berlin and Paris are likely to find sympathy among the EU's 28
member states, domestic security issues are not a competence of the
European Union. The best that may be hoped for is a public expression of
support from leaders and calls for a full explanation from the United
States.
On their way into the summit, several European leaders did express their shock and surprise at the spying allegations.
"This is serious," said Dutch Prime Minister Mark Rutte.
"I will support (Merkel) completely in her complaint and say that
this is not acceptable. I think we need all the facts on the table
first."
DATA PRIVACY RULES
The most immediate impact of the furor could be to encourage member
states to back tougher data privacy rules currently being drafted by the
European Union. The European Parliament this week approved proposed
legislation that would overhaul EU data protection rules that date from
1995.
The new rules would restrict how data collected in Europe by firms
such as Google and Facebook is shared with non-EU countries, introduce
the right of EU citizens to request that their digital traces be erased,
and impose fines of 100 million euros ($138 million) or more on rule
breakers.
The United States is concerned that the regulations, if they enter
into law, will raise the cost of doing business and handling data in
Europe. Google, Yahoo!, Microsoft and others have lobbied hard against
the proposals.
Given the spying accusations, France and Germany - the two most
influential countries in EU policy - may succeed in getting member
states to push ahead on negotiations with the parliament to complete the
data regulations and make them tougher.
That could mean an agreement is reached early next year, with the
laws possibly coming into force in 2015. For the United States, this
could substantially change how data privacy rules are implemented
globally.
It may also complicate relations between the United States and the
EU over an agreement to share a large amount of data collected via
Swift, the international system used for transferring money
electronically, which is based in Europe.
Among the revelations from Snowden's leaks is that the United States
may have violated the Swift agreement, accessing more data than it was
allowed to.
The European Parliament voted on Wednesday to suspend Swift, and the
spying accusations may make EU member states support a firm line,
complicating the United States' ability to collect data it says is
critical in combating terrorism.
Despite the outrage in Paris and Berlin, the former head of France's
secret services said the issue was being blown out of proportion and no
one should be surprised by U.S. spying.
"I'm bewildered by such worrying naiveté. You'd think the
politicians don't read the reports they're sent - there shouldn't be any
surprise," Bernard Squarcini told Le Figaro.
"The agencies know perfectly well that every country, even when they
cooperate on anti-terrorism, spies on its allies. The Americans spy on
us on the commercial and industrial level like we spy on them, because
it's in the national interest to defend our businesses. No one is
fooled."