There can be no possible comparison between what was said
about McDaniel and the Protocols, because what was said about McDaniel
is true: he is a racist…
Glenn Beck, by comparing charges that a repugican candidate who associates with white supremacists and
retweets anti-Semitic
stuff like “Pro-Kremlin Lawmaker Says jews Destroyed Russia in 1917 and
1991,” is a racist, to the anti-Semitic Protocols of the Elders of
Zion, owes the world’s jews an apology, for he has
put a Sarah Palin in his mouth, one that ranks right up there with the Wasilla grifter’s “blood libel” remarks.
Here is how Beck came to go full-tilt Sarah Palin: We have seen how Sarah Palin’s candidate
for US Senate, Mississippi State Senator Chris McDaniel, was defeated
in the primary runoff election by incumbent Thad Cochran. We have seen
how Palin and others are insisting that only leftist shenanigans made
Cochran’s defeat possible. Palin even took to Facebook to put her ignorance of the political system to work for her and her intellectually bankrupt followers, claiming that,
As we pointed out last
week (see: http://t.co/y8T64iZQyR), there were several potentially
illegal political games afoot in Mississippi to motivate Democrat voters
to “switch” over to the repugican cabal for a day to help save a 42 year repugican
member of Congress.
Crying foul play, saying he will challenge the results, McDaniel was still refusing to concede. Glenn Beck took the hysteria a step farther,
crying Tuesday
that ” I got news for you gang: we’ve been played! We’re pawns. Period.
Period.” then whining that McDaniel was smeared with “bogus race
charges” which he compared to the Protocols of the Elders of Zion:
It’s the Protocols of
the Elders of Zion. That’s really what we’re turning into. What a
surprise, ‘Protocols of the Elders of Zion,’ oh, that’s right, that was a
Marxist-Communist thing. I forgot all about that. How interesting it
is that history always repeats itself.
And not only did he get his facts wrong, both about
McDaniel’s very genuine racism but the origins of the Protocols, but
Beck did it by going all-out racist himself, ranting about black folks
wanting “free stuff”:
Here’s the full quote:
Everybody wants their
free stuff and when they’re not just talking about getting their free
stuff, here’s what they are talking about: Race. Bogus race charges. If
you can’t get people to buy in on free stuff, well, then you have to
make somebody out to be the bogey man. You have to say, “Well, at least
Thad Cochran isn’t trying to drink the blood of African Americans and is
quite honestly making matzah balls out of the little christian children
over here too.” [Here Beck is quite pointedly playing off the ancient christian claim that jews drank the blood of christian children, and
applying it to his hero, Chris McDaniel, who just happens to be a christian anti-Semite.]
It’s the Protocols of the Elders of Zion. That’s
really what we’re turning into. What a surprise, ‘Protocols of the
Elders of Zion,’ oh, that’s right, that was a Marxist-Communist thing. I
forgot all about that. How interesting it is that history always
repeats itself.
The Protocols of the Elders of Zion is a piece of christian anti-Semitic propaganda dating from 1903, in the very christian, very anti-Semitic and wingnut Russia of the Czars. The
Holocaust Encyclopedia explains its purpose:
The Protocols of the
Elders of Zion is the most notorious and widely distributed antisemitic
publication of modern times. Its lies about jews, which have been
repeatedly discredited, continue to circulate today, especially on the
Internet. The individuals and groups who have used the Protocols are all
linked by a common purpose: to spread hatred of jews.
…
Although the exact origin of the Protocols is
unknown, its intent was to portray jews as conspirators against the
state. In 24 chapters, or protocols, allegedly minutes from meetings of
Jewish leaders, the Protocols “describes” the “secret plans” of jews to
rule the world by manipulating the economy, controlling the media, and
fostering religious conflict.
Nor is the Protocols a “Marxist-Communist” thing as
Beck claims. Not only did the Protocols come out of wingnut Czarist
Russia, but according to the
Holocaust Encyclopedia,
was spread to the West by anti-communist Russian émigrés. The fables
were embraced by Henry Ford and was even published in Arabic in the
1920s, even though in 1921 the London Times labeled it “clumsy
plagiarism” and revealed its origins to be a French political satire,
Maurice Joly’s
Dialogues in Hell Between Machiavelli and Montesquieu (1864), which had nothing to do with jews at all.
In fact, the most famous fan of the Protocols was
not a Marxist-Communist but a wingnut ethnic nationalist named Adolf
Hitler. He was introduced to them by Alfred Rosenberg, also in the
1920s. As the
Holocaust Encyclopedia explains,
Hitler referred to the
Protocols in some of his early political speeches, and, throughout his
career, he exploited the myth that “jewish-Bolshevists” were conspiring
to control the world.
During the 1920s and 1930s, The Protocols of the
Elders of Zionplayed an important part in the Nazis’ propaganda arsenal.
The Nazi party published at least 23 editions of the Protocols between
1919 and 1939. Following the Nazis’ seizure of power in 1933, some
schools used the Protocols to indoctrinate students.
There can be no possible comparison between what was
said about Chris McDaniel and the Protocols of the Elders of Zion,
because what was said about McDaniel is true:
he is a racist. And the real problem here for wingnuts, as
Brian Beutler writes at New Republic, is that Thad Cochran highlighted Chris McDaniel’s racism.
Millions have died because of the bogus Protocols.
Nobody died in Mississippi because Thad Cochran told the truth about
Chris McDaniel’s racism. Glenn Beck owes jews an apology for even
suggesting that the two have anything in common. As Elie Wiesel said,
“If ever a piece of writing could produce mass hatred, it is this one. .
. . This book is about lies and slander.”
Lies and slander fully embraced by Glenn Beck.
Chris McDaniel’s defeat at the hands of Thad Cochran had nothing to do with lies and slander
about him, as Glenn Beck insists, and
everything to do with racist and anti-Semitic lies and slander he himself spread.